Saturday, May 19, 2018

NOTES ON OUR HERITAGE AND THE EUCHARIST

NOTES ON OUR HERITAGE AND THE EUCHARIST
Rev. Jeric C. Cortado, March 2007

This paper articulates the history and liturgical development of the Eucharist: how it emerged and developed during the time of the early Christians, its survival during the persecution period, how it was lived out by our fore-parents during the time of the Reformation, and how it was celebrated during the Constantinian period and its transition.  This paper also looks at how the Methodist society from England to America, and from America to the Philippines regarded the Eucharist.  Lastly, this paper tries to draw out the political image and implications of the Eucharist in the narration of history of the Christian and Methodist movements.

THE EUCHARIST IN THE EARLY CHRISTIAN MOVEMENT
The early Christians inherited the monotheistic exclusivity of worship, demanding for a renunciation of the worship of other gods from the Jewish tradition.  Christian Jews, at least for the first few decades of the Christian movement, appear to have continued their participation in synagogues, in temple-based religious activities and events in Jerusalem. Paul, the apostle to the Gentile, continued determinedly his Jewish religious associations, most markedly demonstrated in his repeated willingness to undergo synagogue floggings, which were dispensed as punishment for unspecified violations of Jewish religiousness as judged by synagogue authorities (2 Cor.11:24). The exclusivity of Christian worship did not extend to a refusal to participate in Jewish worship. The obvious reason is that the God of the earliest Christians was understood to be the God of the Old Testament and Israel, the God worshipped in the synagogue and Jerusalem temple.[1]  The early Christians led by the Apostles had no sacred places, no shrines, no imposing temple structures, no impressive processions and sacrificial rites, unlike the Roman-era religion.  Christian gatherings then, including the celebration of the Eucharist, would have seemed to be an unimpressive affair.

Larry W. Hurtado summarized the features that the first century Christians offered and contributed in the history of the Church, namely, intimacy[2], participation[3], fervour[4], significance[5], and potency[6]. The physical setting in the earliest Christian worship was the home. And since the common meal was the central component of first-century worship, the setting of worship was in the dining area of the home that accommodated more than nine. The size of the house-church group and the characteristic central place of a shared meal in the worship practice contributed social intimacy and strong solidarity among the participants.  Christians referred to one another as brothers and sisters, children of the same God-Parent, and members of the one body (1st Corinthians 12:27). The intimacy of fellowship was in principle to be extended to all members, regardless of their individual social status, economic standing, and gender. As what Apostle Paul stressed to the Christian movement of Galatia (in Galatians 3:28), “there is no difference between Jews and Gentiles, between slaves and free people, between men and women; you are all one in union with Christ Jesus.”  The early Christian movement paved the opportunities for women to have visible responsibility and respect as acknowledged leaders, including open participation in public liturgical life.  The participation in the corporate worship by those in lower social and economic status including the slaves are widely manifested and spread in the early Christian movement.

Religious fervour has been an impressive character and feature of the Christian movement during the first century.  Their gathering and Eucharistic celebrations is a scene in which jubilation and fervour were collectively expressed and deepened their mutual encouragement. Although their setting in worship was so simple, a house-church, each of them were encouraged which gave a profound significance to their gatherings. And this kind of gathering of members of the Christian movement, the “ekklesia,” was born. In the Greek usage, “ekklesia” designated the gathering of citizens of a city to conduct civic business. “The other important use of “ekklesia’ outside the New Testament is the Greek Old Testament (the Bible of most early Christians, whether Jews or Gentiles) where it is regularly used to refer to Israel as the ‘congregation’ of the Lord (“ekklesia Kyriou”, e.g., Deut, 23:2, I Chronicles 28:8, is most often translated from the Hebrew term “qahal”). In the Old Testament usage, “ekklesia” designates Israel as summoned by God to assemble for some act of obedience.”[7]  The meal fellowship of the early Christian movement is an event where Christ is present in power for good toward those believers who are aligned with his purposes and for potential judgment towards whose who do not recognize that the gathered “ekklesia” is the body of Christ, our Lord.

The early Christians celebrated a full common meal with prayers of blessings patterned after the Jewish table blessings and prayed before and after the meal. William H. Willimon presented the seven-action pattern that is rooted in the sacred meal of the Jewish faithful in Judaism: taking bread, thanking God, breaking bread, giving the bread, taking the wine after the meal, thanking God, and giving the wine. The fellowship meal in 1st Corinthians 11 is a concrete example of the full meal by the early Christians. But as the church moved into the third century, the seven-action pattern of the full common meal was compressed into a four-action pattern of (1) taking bread and wine, (2) thanking God over the bread and wine, (3) breaking the bread, and (4) giving the bread and wine. The Lord’s Supper was separated from the full meal.  Perhaps the reason was the increasing number of the Christians that large groups became impractical for domestic table-gatherings at a private home, and the abuse crept into the celebration, against which Paul spoke and strongly condemned in 1st Corinthians 11:17-34.  It was in the opening of the second century when the sacred meal of the early Christians was generally called “Eucharist” or “Thanksgiving.”

The first century Christian worship derived from the blended Synagogue Worship and Upper Room experience. We inherited in the synagogue worship the following:
  • Scripture lections (1 Tim. 4:13; I Thess. 5:27; Col. 4:16)
  • Psalms and Hymns (I Cor. 14:26; Eph. 5:19; Col. 3: 16)
  • Common Prayers (Acts 2:42; 1 Tim. 2:1-2)
  • People’s Amen (1 Cor. 14: 16)
  • A sermon or exposition (I Cor. 14:26; Acts 20:7)
  • A Confession of Faith, not necessarily the formal recitation of creed (I Cor. 15:1-4; I Tim. 6:12)
  • Alms giving (1 Cor. 16:1-2; 2 Cor. 9:10-13; Rom. 15:26)

We inherited the experience in the Upper Room:
  • The Lord’s Supper (I Cor. 15:16, 11:23; Matt. 24:26-28); Mark 24:22-24; Luke 22: 19-20)
  • The Prayer of Consecration would include thanksgiving (Luke 22:19; I Cor. 11:23, 14:16; I Tim. 2:1)
  • Remembrance of the Lord’s death and resurrection (Acts 2:42; Luke 22:19; I Cor. 11:23,25,26)
  • Intercession (John 17)
  • The recitations of the Lord’s Prayer (Matt. 6:9-13; Luke 11:2-4).
  • Singing in this part of the service, and the Kiss of Peace (Rom. 16:16; I Cor. 16:20; I Thess. 5:26; I Pet. 5:14)
  • Men and women were separated as in the synagogues; the men were bareheaded and the women veiled ( I Cor. 11:6-7)
  • Standing in prayer (Phil. 1:27; Eph.6:14; I Tim.2:8)

Christian Worship is a union of the worship of the synagogue and the sacramental experience of the Upper Room that dates from the New Testament times.

THE EUCHARIST DURING THE ERA OF PERSECUTION
The first persecution of Christians took place in Palestine, particularly, in Jerusalem instigated by the Jewish authorities and puppet to the Roman Imperial power, which has much to do with these persecutions.  Christians were persecuted from the time of emperor Nero to the time of  emperor Diocletian, roughly from the year 60 C.E. to 305 C.E.  In between those years, Christians were forced to lead a quiet and clandestine life. They celebrated the Holy Eucharist secretly, they gathered in the catacombs. They were victims at the same of malicious rumors accusing them of offering human sacrifices, and being cannibals, contributing to a very low regard of the Christian movement on the part of the pagan community.  It was considered as the dark era of the early Christian movement, but gave birth to the golden age of liturgical development.

The Didache (100 C.E.), the earliest liturgical document apart from the New Testament literature, was formed during this persecution era.  This document is closely related to the Kiddush, a combined Eucharistic and agape meal, in which the blessings of the bread and the cup are not only separate, but the cup is blessed before the bread. This document was also known as “The Teaching of the Lord Through the Twelve Apostles” that served as manual for missionary work in the rural communities of Palestine and Syria. The Didache gives explicit instructions to the Christians, “On the Lord’s day meet and break and offer the Eucharist, after having first confessed your offenses, so that your sacrifice may be pure.”[8]  The Didache documents fixed the Sunday, the Lord’s Day to be a day for the celebration of the Eucharist.

The Apologia, probably written in 150 C.E., “describes worship in the church at Rome as a gathering on Sunday, led by a ‘president’ (as yet there seems to be no status distinction between cleros and laos), which begins with reading from the apostles or the writings of the prophets ‘as long as time permits’ followed by a sermon by the president ‘urgently admonishing his hearers to practice these beautiful teachings in their lives.’ ‘Then all stand up together and recite prayers.’ Then bread and wine mixed with water are brought, the president offers prayers of thanksgiving ‘as much as in him lies,’ and the people respond with, ‘Amen.’ The Eucharist is then eaten, and leftovers are gathered by the deacons to take to orphans, widows, and others who are not present.”[9]  The Apologia was written by Saint Justin (100-165 C.E.), who became the first Christian apologist. He wrote two Apologies, the first one (148 C.E.) where he addressed emperor Antoninus Pius presenting that there is nothing immoral and criminal in the Christian gathering and Eucharistic celebrations that the enemies of the Christian movement claimed. The other one (161) is probably an appendix to the first, addressed the Roman Senate. Eventually his enemies, the Roman Imperial power, arrested him and beheaded for his faith. At the middle of the second century, the liturgy written by Saint Justin in his Apologia was reconstructed.

In the liturgy of Justin Martyr, we can see the balance of the sacramental and Scriptural elements. The Word and Table are integral parts of the liturgy and worship. This liturgy was developed at the time when Christians suffered persecution, the Liturgy in the Upper Room and the Prayer of Consecration was kept in secret because they were suspected as cannibal. This secrecy was in high after the death of Justin Martyr and until the death of Constantine, which was also called as the “disciplina arcani”. By the third century, the Sunday worship shape emerged and the actual wording of the Eucharistic prayer, the heart of the Eucharist was written. This was written and developed by Saint Hippolytus in the year 215 C.E. in the context of the ordination of the bishop. The distinguishing characteristic of the Hippolytan Eucharistic prayer is its brevity and simplicity. “First, an Introductory Dialogue (Sursum corda- “Lift up your hearts”) was spoken probably (derived from the synagogue practices) between the bishop and the people:

Bishop: The Lord be with you.
People: And with your Spirit.
Bishop: Lift up your hearts.
People: We have them with the Lord.
Bishop: Let us give thanks (eucharistia) to the Lord.
People: It is right and proper.”[10]

Then the bishop recites the Eucharistic prayer or the Thanksgiving prayer, “We give you thanks, O God through your beloved Son Jesus Christ, whom in these last days you have sent us as Saviour and redeemer and as the angel of your will; he that is your inseparable Word, through whom you made all things, and who is well-pleasing to you; whom you sent from heaven into the womb of a Virgin, and who dwelling within her, was made flesh and was manifested as your Son, born of the Holy Spirit and of the Virgin; who fulfilling your will and winning for himself a holy people, extended his hands when it was time for him to suffer, so that by his suffering he might set free those who believe in you…”[11]  The content of the Eucharistic prayer directly summarizes the core of the apostolic teaching and preaching.

Then the bishop continues to recite the narration of institution emphasizing the passion and suffering of Christ, “When he was betrayed to his voluntary suffering, in order that he might destroy death and break the bonds of the devil and trample hell underfoot and enlighten the just and set a boundary and show forth his resurrection, took bread and gave thanks to you, saying: Take, eat: this is my body, which is broken for you.” Likewise with the cup too, saying: “This is my blood, which is poured out for you. Whenever you do this, you do it in my memory.””[12] This Hippolytan narration of institution stressed one of the joyful triumphs at the victory of Christ in the war of human liberation. This Eucharistic prayer is “an eschatological prayer, a future-oriented prayer which sings a new age in which the whole cosmos is redeemed and all things are being made new.”[13]  Following the words of institution is the so-called anamnesis or remembrance, “Remembering, therefore, his death and resurrection, we offer to you the bread and the cup, giving thanks to you, because of your having accounted us worthy to stand before you and minister to you.”[14] Anamnesis or remembrance here is not something that is remembered from the past, but a “re-presentation” or “re-calling” of some past event, making it present. It is understood as proclamation, participation rather than mere historical recollection.

According to William H. Willimon, a professor of Christian Ministry, “remembering does not mean mere historical recollection. It more nearly means to wake up, to open your eyes, to call to mind, to renew or re-awaken. Remember who you are.”[15] Then follows the Epiclesis or Invocation, asking for a divine response to the church offering in the preceding anamnesis. Asking for the invocation of the Holy Spirit upon the offering and the people gathered together.  “And we pray that your Holy Spirit upon the offering of the holy Church. Gather as one in the fullness of the Holy Spirit your saints who participate; and confirm their faith in truth.” [16] Then the prayer of thanksgiving ends with the concluding doxology, reinforcing the Eucharistic nature of this prayer as a hymn of praise in response to human liberation in Christ.  “So that we may praise and glorify you through your Son Jesus Christ, through whom be glory and honour to you, to the Father and the Son with the Holy Spirit, in your holy Church, both now and through the ages of ages. Amen.”[17] The recitation of “Amen” by all signifies the people’s affirmation and commitment to the mission and ministry of the Christian movement. The faithful then move forward toward the table and receive the Eucharistic bread and wine. After the meal, the leftovers were gathered by the deacons to be distributed to the poor. Then the people depart into the world wrapped by chronic exploitation and greediness. During this period, many Christians were victims of religio-political repression and killings by the empire. But persecutions and repressions brought the Christians to journey together.

THE EUCHARIST DURING THE CONSTANTINIAN ERA
The persecution against Christians ended in 313 C.E. when Emperor Constantine promulgated the Edict of Tolerance and Freedom, and made “peace” with the Christians. Christian worship, gathering and celebrations could be now practiced freely and openly. Christianity flourished and became respectable under the benevolent eyes of the Roman Empire. Towards the end of the fourth century, Christianity became the official and only legitimate religion of the Roman Empire. This was the time that the Christian movement, the people’s movement, was institutionalized and totally captured by the Empire. The empire promoted Christianity as the new state religion, erecting magnificent buildings for worship in Rome, Constantinople, and Jerusalem. Christian worship and Eucharistic celebration was no longer in the catacombs and in house churches but in grandiose basilicas of the Roman Empire. The Eucharist was continued as the central act of Sunday worship, wherein Constantine imposed that Sunday is a day for rest in 321 C.E.

Large buildings modeled on the public buildings of the Roman Empire were built to accommodate Christian Worship. Some temples of the Greek religion were rededicated to Christian worship. In these new settings, Christian worship was developed into impressive ceremonies and rituals.  Impressive entrance ceremonies prior to the reading and preaching of scripture developed. We can notice here the transition of worship under the influence of an imperialist order. Worship increasingly followed fixed text and increased the risk of freedom of worship.  A standard and pattern of Worship was developed and if you did not follow it, you were cursed and tagged as heretic. Participation of the people in worship was reduced and the effectiveness of nurturing faith was alienated. The Eucharistic celebration was centered on the sacrificial suffering and death of Christ rather than on the victorious experience of Christ. The crucifix with the image of the suffering Christ attached to the cross became the major symbol in worship. The Eucharist itself was called Mass and came to understood primarily as sacrifice. Priests were permitted to drink from the cup and laypersons could receive only the bread, which had become a wafer rather than real bread.

Christianity from the start was a dynamic movement of human liberation from selfishness and exploitation. The Holy Eucharist was a corporate public worship of the whole community of believers. It was a Christian gathering openly related to the issues they experienced. “There was an intimate bond between the people and the celebrant. The altar was not distant, as in the big basilicas. There was on going dialogue between the participants. All understood the text read and prayers recited…..The prayer was not individualistic, but communitarian.”[18] But after the institutionalization of the Church and became a Roman Empire religion, Christian worship had been transformed from communal Eucharistic act into a solemn priestly sacrifice and less congregational participation. The Eucharist celebrated at the high altar of the grand Roman basilicas was taken to the corners of the earth by the priests in combination with colonial rulers.

Over the centuries, the Eucharist was exploited and used as means of enslavement and domestication of believers, and adjusted to suit the needs of the elite in the churches.  It tended to be a mechanical ceremony under the control of the priests without much impact on the relationships of persons. The institutionalization of the Christian movement which made Christianity as the official religion of the Roman Empire is a great tragedy of the Christendom. According to Tissa Balasuriya, “the tragedy of the subordination of Christianity to European power politics was also the tragedy of the Eucharist. As the priest and monks went hand in hand with the colonialists, the Eucharist was desecrated in the service of empire,”[19] and even used to contribute mental subjugation of the people.

THE EUCHARIST DURING THE REFORMATION ERA
During the Reformation Era, the issues on sale of indulgences traversed into the realm of worship and liturgy. Questions on the revision of the Mass and its particularities were brought out. Martin Luther and his followers raised a question about why the Mass and the Bible could not be made available in the language of the people. They wanted the passages in the Bible to be read in the hearing of the people, and the Word of God must be proclaimed in the worship. They questioned the prayers of the Church for the dead and to the saints, especially to Mary, and considered this as a corruption of worship. They demanded for more congregational participation in worship, in prayers and in singing. And finally they objected to the doctrine that each Mass the bread and wine became the very body and blood of Jesus Christ—and the sacrifice for man’s redemption was again re-enacted.[20] For them, there is no scriptural basis or support for this.

Martin Luther removed what he believed unnecessary elaborations and returned to the early Christian movement practice. He wrote the first revision called Deutsche Messe (The German Mass) which was printed in 1526. This was an alteration from the Latin Mass and was first used in Wittenberg. In the pre-communion portion the same elements were retained together with lights, vestments, and incense. He did suggest a metrical hymn instead of the introit and in place of the gradual between the Epistle and the Gospel. And he brought back the sermon. The ritual related to the Lord’s Supper and was more drastically changed, particularly the Prayer of Consecration, which retained intact only the words of institution. He returned to the ancient practice of administering the communion in both kinds, that is offering both bread and wine to the communicants.

“He first suggested that communion be received daily, but three years later took the position that the Eucharist should be celebrated every Sunday.  He… modified the doctrine of transubstantiation… that the elements of bread and wine were transformed into the very body and blood of Christ in the Act of Consecration.”[21]  Martin Luther put the words of Jesus, “This is my body”, believing that in the fellowship communion the sacrifice of his life was there. And in participating of that celebration we also sacrifice ourselves together with Christ. Martin Luther pointed out the sacrificial elements in the Holy Eucharist (in the Lord’s Supper) and not simply a re-enactment.  In the Eucharistic Celebration, a sacrificial fellowship and act of true communion, Christ is there, Christ is present. We receive him by our faith and the fullness of his spirit and presence is truly experienced by the people who actively participate.

If Martin Luther regarded the Holy Eucharist as a sacrifice, Zwingli in Northern Switzerland, Zurich, stressed it as a service of fellowship and a memorial.  He did not regard the Holy Eucharist as a means of grace and discouraged frequent celebration of it. He substituted the four prayers in Latin:
1.       A prayer of thanksgiving concluding with the Lord’s Prayer.
2.       A prayer of affirmation, a kind of confession of faith, ending with petitions to increase faith and fellowship.
3.       A prayer that the faithful may be fed the true bread of Heaven,
4.       And a new prayer of humble access, affirming that when the believer cries “Lamb of God, have mercy,” God truly forgives sins.

Zwingli suggested that the institution of the elements is done simply by repeating what St. Paul stated in 1 Corinthians 11:23-26 the words Jesus added “come unto me”. The Holy Eucharist for him is an act of commemoration of Jesus death, the meaning of Jesus’ death in the fellowship of the believers. John Calvin, known among the reformers in Geneva, restored the primitive simplicity and true proportions of the Eucharist. He regarded the Holy Eucharist as the central weekly service and as an act of celebration and communion. He used the ritual translated into French. He wrote the “Form of Prayers and Manners of Ministering the Sacraments According to the Use of the Ancient Church.” He gave emphasis to the Proclamation of the Word in the service and used the simple form of the Lord’s Supper by the early church. The suggested Service was well-phrased, musical and concise, and every aspect of worship should be acted with respect and where the Word was truly proclaimed, and the Sacraments, especially the Holy Eucharist, duly administered. These transitions, changes and developments of Worship and in the Eucharist influenced most the idea of John and Charles Wesley who spearheaded the early Methodist movement in England.

THE EUCHARIST DURING THE METHODIST MOVEMENT OF THE 18TH CENTURY ENGLAND
The Methodist movement in England begun during the second quarter of the eighteenth century.  As we go deeper in our understanding of the Eucharist and the early Methodist movement, as Richard P. Heitzenrater pointed out, “we must first sift the soil which gave it life, look for the seeds from which it sprang, and notice the resources which sustained and nourished it.”[22]  It was during the 6th century when Christianity was introduced in England through St. Augustine of Canterbury, who converted the Saxon King Ehtelbert, whose queen, Bartha, was a Christian.  Christianity in an agricultural and feudal context of society under the monarchial and parliament government of England faced many trials. It was during this time that the Kingdom of England developed its own national identity and consolidated and expanded its territory.  Amidst these efforts, the development of the (Roman) Church in England went along this nationalistic endeavor, was centered in the monarchial power and was strongly anti-papal.  It was Henry VII who took the first step in separating the English Church from the papal supervision based in Rome. The English Parliament by their actions called “Act of Supremacy,” Henry VIII declared to be head of both church and state of England. 

The Roman Church in England became the English Church of England, the official religion of the state and an integral part of the political structure. The polity, the liturgy and even the language was altered to English from Latin. The Church of England originally inclined doctrinally towards Calvin’s Theology, but in liturgical practice it was more closely related to Martin Luther’s perspective.  In 1547 the First Book of Homilies containing the twelve sermons was published. In March 1548, the English Order for Communion prepared by Crammer was issued which was inserted in the first Book of Common Prayer in 1549. The Order stressed that communion should be given in both kinds, that the people should be informed in advance when mass was to be celebrated, and that they should also be instructed on how to prepare for communion. In the Book of Common Prayer, Communion (Eucharist), an essential part of the English rite, was to be celebrated at least every Sunday and Holy Day. The rite was commonly called then, Masse’. Under the regime of Elizabeth, the Book of Common Prayer as revised in 1559 became a common use in England enforced by the law, and another proposed revision of it happened in 1662 and attempted in 1927-28.

The society of John Wesley and Charles Wesley in Oxford was not only called Methodist, they were also called “Sacramentarians”. The Methodist movement in eighteenth-century England was an evangelical movement that included a revival of emphasis on the sacraments. John and Charles Wesley recognized that the power of God was available in the Lord’s Supper and urged their followers to draw on that power by frequent participation. Many writers have noted Wesley’s attempt to make even the Lord’s Supper a converting ordinance. Trevor Dearing wrote, for example, “The Eucharist was, for Wesley, not only a confirming and sanctifying ordinance, but also a converting Means of Grace wherein sinners met their Risen Lord and became assured of their redemption.” It is evident from his Journal that Wesley believed people were at times converted at communion service. There is also evidence that it was a common belief among the associates of Wesley that the sacrament itself had the power to convert.”[23]

In the Journal of John Wesley, the entry of June 28, 1740, articulates that the Lord’s Supper or the Holy Eucharist has a converting power, that it is a converting ordinance of the church. There were four points articulated, “I showed at large, 1. That the Lord’s Supper was ordained by God, to be a means of conveying to men either preventing, or justifying, or sanctifying grace, according to their several necessities. 2. That the persons for whom it was ordained, are all those who know and feel that they want the grace of God, either to restrain them from sin, or to show their sins forgiven, or to renew their souls in the image of God. That inasmuch as we come to his table, not to give him any thing, but to receive whatsoever he sees best for us, there is no previous preparation indispensably necessary, but a desire to receive whatsoever he pleases to give. And, 4. That no fitness is required at the time of communicating, but a sense of our state, of our utter sinfulness and helplessness; every one who knows he is fit for hell, being just fit to come to Christ, in this as well as all other ways of his appointment.”[24]

The prevenient grace in the order of salvation testifies to the divine initiative in all action everywhere and at all times. God acts, and human beings are called upon and motivated to respond. A divine political initiative in governing the world and the people to respond by fulfilling their political vocation intertwined with moral vocation. The prevenient grace is God’s act of caring, establishing a context of grace within which humankind receives its nature as political image. The justifying grace as component of the way of salvation declares the acceptance of humankind of the vocation of imaging God in the governance of the world. By the creative act of God, human beings are placed into that political relationship. By justifying grace people receive the gift of divine forgiveness, and are welcomed to renew the vocation on its original terms. The renewal of life that comes with God’s justification therefore includes the renewal of political vocation. It is the beginning of the realization of the political image of God. What justifying grace reveals to us in the new viewing of the political image is that the fundamental identity of human beings is given in and through the image of God only. It is an identity that all human beings share. Justifying grace reestablishes all of humanity corporately in the political image of God. It is a gift, not something earned, and not something superseded by membership. The gracious renewal of the political vocation of all humankind is an essential aspect of drawing politics into the order of salvation. It is the conjoining of the political image in discerning the full meaning of God’s justifying work in Christ.[25]  Sanctification involves the recovery of the political image of God, and not the moral image only.[26]

John Wesley described the Lords’ Supper (Holy Eucharist) as “the grand channel whereby the grace of his Spirit was conveyed to the souls of all the children of God” (“Sermon on the Mount-Discourse Six,” III.I).[27] John Wesley himself communed on an average of four to five times a week, and since, opened this sacrament to those who are in need of conversion.  He encouraged his followers to participate in the Holy Eucharist as long as they can, and open this to everyone who liked to receive. There are records that described John Wesley as serving the Lord’s Supper in some of their own houses.[28] The Wesley brothers wrote and published a collection of 166 Hymns of the Lord’s Supper, which was used for meditations as well as for singing. They wrote about love, grace, sacrifice, forgiveness, the presence of Christ, mystery, healing, nourishment, holiness, and pledge of heaven. They know that Holy Communion is a powerful means through which divine grace is given to God’s people. 

Although, John Wesley is a conservative Anglican clergy in matters of worship and sacraments, he advocated corporate drama in worship relevant to the people and the times. “Wesley discouraged the use of choirs in worship. He did not write anthems or encouraged their use. If a song was to praise God he believed it should be sung by the whole congregation.”[29] And this temperament of worship was adapted by the American Methodists. The Wesley brothers combined the revivalistic and open field preaching, the organization of bands and society for nurture and social work, and the weekly celebration and administration of the Eucharist.

THE METHODISTS OF 18TH CENTURY NORTH AMERICA AND THE HOLY EUCHARIST
In North America, the first Methodist movement was implanted and organized in a colony of England. They were under the crown of England, nurtured from the European books and colleges.  They were an agricultural society where huge plantations were being built and the products and gains of which were exported to the land of the crown.  Land hunger possessed the people in America. They were victims of oppression, subjugation, and exploitation from the hand of England. The crown of England also supported the establishment of churches in the colonies.  Wesleyan scholars agree that it was in America where the second rise of Methodism happened.  In response to the request of General Oglethorpe for missionaries to the Thirteen Colonies in the New World (America), Rev. Fr. John Wesley sailed for and landed in Savannah, Georgia on February 1736 and stayed for two years, experiencing the ups and downs of ministry. He left Georgia with the seeds of Methodism that later developed into societies of which George Whitefield and Jonathan Edwards were the most widely known in this endeavor at around 1740. George Whitefield who was inspired about the development of Methodism visited America thirteen times. 

The first generation of English Methodists was people from the marginalized class and small traders people. They came from Northern Ireland, and some were artisans and small farmers or peasants. They established a Methodist society starting from a small group that came together to sing hymns, pray, and hear a sermon.  It was Philip Embury, a carpenter and a religious refugee from the Palatinate of the Rhine (Germany) who settled in Limerick, Ireland. He went to America in 1760 and established in 1766 the first Methodist Society (called Wesley Chapel) at Barrack Street (now Park Place), New York. Robert Strawbridge and his wife, both from Ireland, immigrated to America and settled in Frederick County, Maryland. He became the first Methodist preacher in Maryland with his wife who opened their house as a meeting place of the Second Methodist Society which they organized.  John Wesley regarded America as an outpost of the Methodist movement, and at the English Methodist Conference in 1769 he sent the first two preachers Richard Boardman and Joseph Pilmoor to formally organize Methodist societies in America, where from the very start  were diversified racially as well as socially and economically.[30]

Among the important feature of the early American Methodist movement was their small group meetings which played a vital role in the development of American Methodist societies. In many places and in most cases the small groups of Methodists gathered and met in homes. The “Book of Worship for Church and Home” directed their gathering and worship activities which reflected eighteenth century Methodism. One of the innovations that the Moravians inspired in John Wesley and which became one of the features in Methodism was the Love Feast.  He first experienced this when he was in Georgia with Moravian missionaries. The love feast was adapted by American Methodist societies and played an important part in the history of American Methodist worship. It became popular and became an alternative during the time that the Methodist movement was deprived of the opportunity and privilege to receive the Eucharist from Anglican Churches and when there was a shortage of Methodist clergy to administer the same.  Even when the Holy Eucharist became part of the worship experience of American Methodists, they did not abandon the love feast, which was used commonly during the closing service of camp meetings and conferences. It was March 23, 1770, when the Methodist missionaries began holding the love feast and marked the first celebration held in America (Philadelphia). The order includes scripture reading, singing, praying, the sharing of the bread and water and testimonies, and since then were held quarterly. 

With the arrival of Francis Asbury in America in 1771 who was appointed by John Wesley as his “assistant” or superintendent of the American Methodist Societies, the Wesleyan pattern of worship was used by the Methodist societies. Methodists were urged to participate in the sacramental worship of the Anglican Church, they received the sacraments of Baptism and Holy Eucharist from the Anglican clergy. And among the Anglican clergy who was supportive in this matter and even helped to organize Methodist societies was the Rev. Fr. Devereux Jarrat.  Worship for the Methodist movement is vital, especially the celebration of the sacraments, the Holy Eucharist.  In the first American Methodist Conference held in Philadelphia in 1773, questions arose on matters of the administration of the sacraments. In the belief that sacraments are an important ordinance to be received and participated in by the people, and in the importance of receiving it from ordained clergy, problems arise. There were difficulties in finding clergy who can officiate the sacraments of Baptism and Eucharist. There were a lot of areas of Methodist societies who had no ordained clergy, and so they requested John Wesley to address the problems encountered in the colonies.

There was a long time of waiting, for it was only in November 3, 1784, that the American Methodists were rewarded by the arrival of Thomas Coke, a Doctor of Civil Law and a Presbyter in the Church of England.  He was commissioned as John Wesley’s assistant or superintendent of the Methodist Societies in America and to ordain with Rev. Francis Asbury as co-superintendent.  Richard Whatcoat, and Thomas Vasey also arrive in New York with their certificate of ordination signed by John Wesley. And during the Christmas Conference held at Lovely Lane Chapel in Baltimore, Maryland in December 27 (24), 1784 and ended in January 2, 1785, attended by 60 preachers, Thomas Coke and Francis Asbury were elected bishops or general superintendents in the newly constituted Church. In the last day of the conference they decided to establish the Methodist Episcopal Church in America.  The conference also acted that the sacramental worship be lived out, that worship was not to be separated from the total life of the church. The Methodist societies were able to receive the Eucharist quarterly when the ordained minister came to the community.  Participation in the Holy Eucharist was part of the lifestyle of the Methodist society as an outward sign of that lifestyle. It was also during the Christmas Conference when the copy of “The Sunday Service of the Methodist in North America” prepared by John Wesley was accepted, but this was never popularized as a guide to worship in some instances. Articles of Religion, forms of administration of the Sacraments and for the ordination were also decided upon and created.

Aiming for uniformity in worship, on December 1, 1789, Bishop Francis Asbury called a clergy meeting (ordained elders), to discuss the possibility of having time and form of public worship as similar as possible through out the Methodist congregations. This gathering attempted to establish a uniform practice of worship, and to commence public worship on Sunday morning at 10:00 o’clock, if not, at 11:00 o’clock. The worship shall compose of singing, prayer and reading the Bible, sermon or reading the sermon in the absence of the preacher.  The officiating person shall be appointed by the Elder, Deacon, or Traveling Preacher assigned. The endeavor of having a uniform public worship appears to have been unsuccessful.  In 1792, “The Sunday Service of the Methodist in North America” was dropped and the ritual became part of “The Book of Discipline” with thorough and relevant revision.

Because of the intense racial discrimination by the whites of the blacks, a group of Black Methodists led by Richard Allen separated in 1816 and established the African Methodist Episcopal Church.  Another split happened in 1821 due to the same reason and the new group called themselves the African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church. Dissatisfied by the administration of the Pastors and Bishops of the Methodist Episcopal Church, a group of lay people separated and established the Methodist Protestant Church in 1830. In 1845, due to the issues of slavery tolerated by the Methodist Episcopal Church, the Methodist Episcopal Church South (MECS) was formed in 1845. From the MECS some black people separated and established another group called The Colored Methodist Episcopal Church [ or The Christian Methodist Episcopal Church] in 1870. In 1939, the Methodist Episcopal Church, the Methodist Protestant Church and the Methodist Episcopal Church South organically merged and they called themselves The Methodist Church.  It was in the 23rd of April 1968 in Dallas, Texas, in a Uniting Conference, that The Methodist Church and the Evangelical United Brethren merged and called themselves since then, The United Methodist Church.

In 1892, the General Conference of the northern church tried to attempt again to establish uniformity of public worship.  The fact that the Methodist both south and north shared a common understanding and attitude in worship, it helped them to encouraged each other in union in 1939. In 1905 they both adopted the “The Methodist Hymnal” which have only change little since.  Although there were efforts for public worship uniformity, the major thrust of the American Methodist movement was how to meet the demands of a particular setting and people, a relevant, engaging, and mass-oriented public worship. The purpose of Methodist worship and the Holy Eucharist celebrations was to save people and to keep the people saved, an attempt to bring new life to the church, and help the people become aware of their experience of reality and increase the level of their commitment. Rituals and practices established by the American Methodist movement have great influence in the ritual and practices of the Methodist movement in the Philippines.

After so many years of ups and downs in the journey in the sacramental life of the Methodist Church, from the “Sunday Service of the Methodist of North America” written by John Wesley in 1784 down through the hymnals, rituals, and book of worship from our antecedent societies and denominations, the official worship resources now carry the name the United Methodist Church. Out from our Anglican liturgical heritage, our Methodist and Evangelical United Brethren traditions, from our ethnic and cultural diversity, The United Methodist Hymnal came about in 1989 as approved by the General Conference of the United Methodist Church in 1988. Second, The United Methodist Book of Worship came about, that speaks of our corporate and collective worship, that strengthens our worship life and empowers our ministry and mission. The current official Hymnal and Book of Worship are composed of psalms, responses, and hymns suited to all seasons and occasions celebrates by the community, the complete and brief form of the order of worship, the order for the confirmation and reception of the church, the order for the administration of the Holy Baptism and the Holy Eucharist.

During the session of the General Conference of the United Methodist Church held last May 2004 in the United States of America, the General Board of Discipleship presented the draft on “This Holy Mystery: A United Methodist Understanding of Holy Communion” (THM), which discusses the theological understanding, historical tradition and celebration, and articulates the challenge to live out the Sacrament of Communion.  It was adopted by the General Conference, and duly approved for print, copy, distribution, and use for non-profit education by individuals, local congregations, and agencies of the United Methodist Church.  This action reflects the effort of United Methodism to reclaim its sacramental heritage and to continue it in accord with ecumenical movements in sacramental theology and practice. The THM is an official interpretive statement of theology and practice in the United Methodist Church that urges wide use and implementation. The General Conference resolved that “the Council of Bishops and several agencies use THM as a guide for teaching and formation of both clergy and laity in relationship to Holy Communion (The Holy Eucharist); that the General Commission on Christian Unity and Inter-Religious Concerns and the Council of Bishops use THM in interpreting United Methodist understandings and practices in ecumenical dialogue; that the “principles,” “background,” and “practices” statements in THM be commended to the church for their interpretation and use in the services of Word and Table in the hymnals and Book of Worship; and that THM be published in The Book of Resolutions, and that the General Board of Discipleship provide it in study editions with a leader’s guide.”[31]

Here in the Philippines, some of the annual conferences are now doing workshops and studies to popularize the THM, and have started to implement it.  The Mindanao Central East District of the Mindanao Philippines Annual Conference is among those that are now living it out.  It started with a District-wide Seminar and Workshop on the Holy Eucharist last conference year 2005-2006 participated by Pastors, Deaconesses, and lay people involved in worship leadership.  When the participants went back to their local churches, they implemented what they learned by holding weekly celebrations of the Eucharist, and re-echoed what they learned by in turn educating their constituents.  In my church assignment during my internship, we started to have weekly celebrations in June 2005.  Reorientation and re-education about the Eucharist was integrated into the Sunday school lessons, sermons, and Cell group discussions.  The Pioneer United Methodist Church under the administration of Rev. Ernesto Ramos and the Little Cochran United Methodist Church under the administration of Ptr. Primero Laforteza are still going on with their sacramental journey and deepening their understanding on the Holy Eucharist by weekly celebration. Some local churches celebrate twice a month, and the rest still celebrate on the first Sunday of the month while in the process of studying about the Eucharist. 

At the beginning of each conference year, the district, through the leadership of District Superintendent Ernesto Ramos, conducts workshops on worship to ensure the capacity of the pastor in leading the worship, and in order to be relevant and rooted in the life-situations of the church and society.  It was June 25-26, 2004, under the administration of Rev. Manuel R. Rapisura, that a consultation was held that resulted in the creation of a quadrennial vision-mission.  “Inspired by the vision-mission of our Lord Jesus Christ: ‘I come that they might have life, and that they might have it more abundantly’ (John 10:10), the Mindanao Central East District will lead and empower the local churches in making disciples of the Lord in all rural and urban communities within the area of responsibility of the district.”[32] It clarifies the vision-mission of Jesus Christ for the welfare of the people, living out the gospel of truth, love, righteousness, justice, and peace. In the worship life of the district, in order to have a joyful, meaningful and liberating liturgy in the local churches, the district defined their particular objectives: [1] to conduct study on liturgy suited to the present time and cultural situation of the churches; [2] to conduct workshops on contextual and relevant liturgies; [3] to have a workshop-training on learning worship songs and hymns, hymnody, etc; [4] develop and deepen the knowledge of the meaning and importance of worship; [5] to organize junior and children’s worship in the local churches. A seminar in Liturgy and Worship was conducted on July 9-10, 2004. 

In September 9-10, 2005, under the leadership of Rev. Abelardo N. Guerrero as newly appointed District Superintendent, a Seminar Workshop on Holy Eucharist and Our Social Principles on the Natural World was held at Little Cochran United Methodist Church, Bulakanon, Makilala, Cotabato.  After the input on “The Celebration of the Holy Eucharist: Its Mandate and Theology,” the clergy and lay leaders of the local churches present then held a workshop on conducting and celebrating the sacrament. It was then that the leadership of the Mindanao Central East District (MCED) urged all local churches under it to celebrate the Holy Eucharist every Sunday. One of the components in the nurture ministries of the MCED in their One Year Action Plan for Conference Year 2006-2007 is the Liturgical Renewal Workshop which aims to propagate understanding by the church workers and laity the Biblico-Theological foundations of Worship, space and movements in worship, and to develop worship leaders. ###

References:
1.        Baker, Frank. METHODISM AND LOVE-FEAST. London: The Epworth Press, 1957.
2.        Balasuriya, Tissa. OMI. THE EUCHARIST AND HUMAN LIBERATION. New York: Orbis Books, 1979.
3.        Bedell, Kenneth B. Worship in the Methodist Tradition. USA: Discipleship Resources Tidings, 1976.
4.        Best, Thomas F. and Heller Dagmar (eds.). EUCHARISTIC WORSHIP IN
5.        ECUMENICAL CONTEXT: The Lima Liturgy – and Beyond. Switzerland: WCC Publications, 1998.
6.        __________________________________. Se We Believe, So We Pray: Towards Koinonia in Worship. Switzerland: WCC Publications, 1995.
7.        Cameron, Richard M. METHODISM AND SOCIETY IN HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE. Vol. 1. USA: Abingdon Press, 1961.
8.        Crossan, John Dominic. Jesus: A Revolutionary Biography. USA: Harper Collins Publishers, Inc., 1994.
9.        Deats, Richard L. NATIONALISM AND CHRISTIANITY IN THE PHILIPPINES. Dallas: Southern Methodist University Press, 1967.
10.     Elwood, Douglas J. and Magdamo, Patricia L. CHRIST IN THE PHILLIPINE CONTEXT. Quezon City: New Day Publishers, 1971.
11.     Garneau, Jean-Yves. DISCOVERING THE EUCHARIST: According to a Ritual Approach. Philippines: St. Paul, 1990.
12.     Glatzer, Nahum N. (ed.). THE PASSOVER HAGGADAH. New York: Schocken Books, 1979.
13.     Hann, Ferdinand. The Worship of the Early Church. USA: Fortress Press, 1973.
14.     Heitzenrater, Richard P. WESLEYAN and the People Called Methodist. USA: Abingdon Press, 1995.
15.     Hellwig, Monika K. THE EUCHARIST & THE HUNGER OF THE WORLD. Makati City: St. Pauls Philippines, 2003.
16.     Hickman, Hoyt L. Worshipping With United Methodist: A Guide for Pastors and Church Leaders. Nashville: Abingdon Press, 1996.
17.     Hurtado, Larry H. At the ORIGINS of CHRISTIAN WORSHIP: The Context and  Character of Earliest Christian Devotion. USA: William B. Eerdmans Publishing Company, 1999.
18.     Khoo, Lorna Lock-Nah. Wesleyan Eucharistic Spirituality: Its Nature, Sources and Future. Australia: Australian Theological Forum Press, 2005.
19.     Kodell, Jerome. OSB. The Eucharist in the New Testament.  Manila: St. Pauls Philippines, 1995.
20.     Langford, Thomas Anderson III (Gen. Ed.). THE UNITED METHODIST BOOK OF WORSHIP. USA: The United Methodist Publishing House, 2002.
21.     Marquardt, Manfred. John Wesley’s Social Ethics: Praxis and Principles. USA: Abingdon Press, 1992.
22.     Martin, Ralph P. WORSHIP IN THE EARLY CHURCH. Grand Rapids: William B. Eerdmans Publishing Company, 2000.
23.     Maxwell, William D. An Outline of CHRISTIAN WORSHIP: Its Developments and Forms. Great Britain: Oxford University Press, 1960.
24.     Nolan, Albert. Jesus Before Christianity. Quezon City: Claretian Publications, 1985.
25.     Pazmiño, Robert W. Foundational Issues in Christian Education: An Introduction in Evangelical Perspective. USA: Baker Books, 2003.
26.     Rieger, Joerg. and Vincent, John J. METHODIST AND RADICAL: Rejuvenating a Tradition. USA: Kingswood Books, Abingdon Press, 2003.
27.     Tejon, Guillermo. OP. The MASS We Celebrate. Pasay City: Paulines Publishing House, 1997.
28.     Vaño, Manolo O. Discovering the Original Jesus: A Biography of a Revolutionary Genius as He was Actively Known to His Contemporaries. Quezon City: New Day Publisher, 1998.
29.     Voigt, Edwin E. METHODIST WORSHIP IN THE UNIVERSAL CHURCH. USA: Graded Press, 1965.
30.     Weber, Theodore R. POLITICS IN THE ORDER OF SALVATION: Transforming Wesleyan Political Ethics. USA: Abingdon Press, 2001.
31.     White, James F. INTRODUCTION TO CHRISTIAN WORSHIP. USA: Abingdon Press, 1980.
32.     Willimon, William H. SUNDAY DINNER: The Lord’s Supper and the Christian Life. USA: The Upper Room, 1981.
33.     _________________. Word, Water, Wine and Bread: How Worship Has Changed over the Years. USA: Judson Press, 1980.
34.     Willimon, William H. and Wilson, Robert L. “Preaching and Worship in the Small Church” in Creative Leadership Series. Ed. By Lyle E. Schaller. USA: Abingdon Press, 1980.
35.     THE UNITED METHODIST HYMNAL. USA: The United Methodist Publishing House, 2005.
36.     THE UNITED METHODIST BOOK OF WORSHIP. USA: The United Methodist Publishing House, 2002.
37.     THE UNITED METHODIST BOOK OF DISCIPLINE. USA: The United Methodist Publishing House, 2000.
38.     Anno, Ferdinand C. “Doing Worship in the Context of a People’s Struggle for Life” in The Union Seminary Bulletin. Yr. 1. Vol. 1, November 2002.
39.     _______________. “The Subversive Pilgrim and the Liturgical Rhetoric of Struggle” in ANUMANG HIRAP, KUNG HINDI MASIKIP AY MALUWANG: Iba’t-Ibang Anyo ng Teolohiyang Pumipiglas. Published by the Union Theological Seminary, 2006.
40.     OFFICIAL JOURNAL of the 41st Regular Session of the Mindanao Philippines Annual Conference- United Methodist Church, 7th to 10th day of March 1996.
41.     OFFICIAL JOURNAL of the 42 Regular Session of the Mindanao Philippines Annual Conference-United Methodist Church, 20th to 23rd day of March 1997.
42.     OFFICIAL JOURNAL of the Regular Session of the Mindanao Philippines Annual Conference – United Methodist Church, 1994.
43.     Fuentes, Vilma May (et.al.) “METHODISM IN THE LAND OF PROMISE” in 50th Anniversary Souvenir Program of the Mindanao Philippines Annual Conference (1955-2005) – United Methodist Church, May 2005.
44.     Larranga, Jose Miguel, SSS. “The Eucharist in the Theology of Liberation” in The Emmanuel. Philippine Edition, 2001.
45.     Ang Adhikain para sa Affiliated Autonomy: Isang Praymer. Philippines: Caucus Philippines.
46.     This Holy Mystery: A United Methodist Understanding of Holy Communion. USA: General Board of Discipleship of the United Methodist Church, 2004.
47.     HISTORICAL ACCOUNT of the Calaoaan United Methodist Church, Candon City. [Photocopied].
48.     HISTORICAL ACCOUNT of the Pioneer United Methodist Church, J.P. Laurel St., Poblacion B, Mlang, North Cotabato. [Encoded].
49.     HISTORICAL ACCOUNT of the Living Water United Methodist Church, Katidtuan, Kabacan, North Cotabato. [Photocopied].







[1] Larry W. Hurtado, At the ORIGINS of CHRISTIAN WORSHIP: The Context and Character of Earliest Christian Devotion, (USA: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Company, 2000) pp.39-40.
[2] Ibid.
[3] Ibid.,p.44.
[4] Ibid., p.46.
[5] Ibid.,p.49.
[6] Ibid., p.56.
[7] Ibid., p.55.
[8] William H. Willimon, WORD, Water, Wine and Bread: How Worship Has Changed over the Years, (USA: Judson Press, 1980), pp. 33-34.
[9] Ibid.
[10] Ibid, p. 35.
[11] Guillermo Tejon, o.p., The Mass We Celebrate, (Pasay City, Philippines: Paulines Publishing House, 1997),pp.35-36.
[12] Ibid, p.36.
[13] William H. Willimon, WORD, Water, Wine and Bread: How Worship Has Changed over the Years, p. 37.
[14] Guillermo Tejon, Op. cit., p. 36.
[15] William H. Willimon, Sunday Dinner: The Lord’s Supper and the Christian Life, (Nashville, Tennessee: The Upper Room, 1981), p.21.
[16] Guillermo Tejon,  p. 36.
[17] Ibid.
[18] Tissa Balasuriya, o.m.i, The Eucharist and Human Liberation, (USA: Orbis Books, 1979) p.27.
[19] Ibid.,p.37.
[20] Edwin E. Voigt, METHODIST WORSHIP IN THE CHURCH UNIVERSAL, (Nashville, USA: Graded Press, 1965), p.46.
[21] Ibid.
[22] Richard P. Heitzenrater, WESLEY AND THE PEOPLE CALLED METHODIST, (USA: Abingdon Press, 1995),p. 2.
[23] Kenneth B. Bedell, Worship in the Methodist Tradition, (USA: Discipleship Resources Tidings, 1976), pp. 26-27.
[24] Ibid, pp. 27-28.
[25] Theodore R. Weber, POLITICS IN THE ORDER OF SALVATION: Transforming Wesleyan Political Ethics, (USA: Abingdon Press, 2001),pp.412-413.
[26] Ibid, pp.413-414.
[27] Ibid.
[28] Ibid, p.63.
[29] Kenneth B. Bedell, Worship in the Methodist Tradition, p. 16.
[30] Richard M. Cameron, METHODISM AND SOCIETY IN HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE, volume 1, (USA: Abingdon Press, 1961), p.87.
[31] Benedict Daniel, O.S.L., “This Holy Mystery: Moving from Paper to Practice”, Sacramental Life. Volume XVI, number 4, (USA: Order of Saint Luke, Fall 2004), p. 805.
[32] Noted from the report of Rev. Manuel R. Rapisura, District Superintendent (2004-2005) of the Mindanao Central East District during the regular session of the Mindanao Philippines Annual Conference held at Branscomb UMC, SMC, Kidapawan City, 2005. 

NOTES ON CHRISTIAN LITURGY IN THE ACTIONS OF THE EUCHARIST

NOTES ON CHRISTIAN LITURGY IN THE ACTIONS OF THE EUCHARIST
 Rev. Jeric C. Cortado, March 2007

Understanding the Actions for Life
We always meet the term “worship”, “liturgy” and “Eucharist”, but the question is, what are their meanings? What is liturgy? What is worship?  And what does the Eucharist mean?

Liturgy is a term that comes from the Geek word “leitourgia” which means “work or actions of the people,” or “a service of the people and for the people.” The word “leitourgia” is a composite word of “leitos” (from “leos” equivalent to “laos” which means people) meaning “public,” and “ergo” which means “to do.”  From this we have “leitourgos,” which means “someone who performs a public duty, and “leitourgia,” the public duty itself.  It seems there is no connection to God. But, if we try to deepen it, “works or actions of the people” or “the service of the people and for the people” are action, work, and service for the Lord. As what the Gospel of Matthew (25:40) says, “…whenever you did this for one of the least important of these followers of mine, you did it for me!” Liturgy gives an “ordo” (pattern) on how our worship may be ordered according to our particular situation.

On the other hand, the term worship comes from the Old English “woertscipe” which means, “giving respect to something or someone”. This term was originally used in connection with giving respect to a king, until it became common usage for giving worth and respect to God. For the Filipino, worship is any action that gives worth to God.  Worship is a celebration of the gospel in which God calls us anew to through the risen Christ, and the Holy Spirit within us enables us to hear and respond. The rhythms of call and response bring us to a communion that unites us with God and with one another, renewing us as the Body of Christ for the world.  Eucharist is derived from the Greek word “eucharesteo,” which means “thanksgiving.”  It reminds us to give thanks to the God who gives life and hope for salvation.  Throughout the centuries, the words of the Eucharist have been maintained but their meaning have been distorted and substituted.

Liturgy and worship is a people’s movement that expresses their aspirations and agenda before God.  A people’s actions that express service to the God we believe in.  it is grounded by our concrete experiences, thanksgiving, aspirations, that strengthens our principles and faith.  Liturgy and worship is a continuing experience of God’s intervention in our life as we continue in our journey and struggles.  Worship is more meaningful when it is the work of the people, when it expresses the concerns and celebrations of the people’s everyday lives. The Roman Catholic Church and the Protestant churches both endorse that the full service of Word and Table be the norm for Sunday Worship which should be an expression of who we are.  The Eucharist then becomes a call to unity, challenging people to commit themselves to a life of dialogue, wherein the attack to life, oppressed lives and abused resources are the agenda.  Wherein, amidst cultural, economic, and political chaos, the seeds of a relevant, engaging, and liberating faith are propagated. Wherein, the profound task and aspiration of nation-building, community building, and social transformation are flaming. Wherein, the spirit of truth and righteousness is the motivating force of the people.  The Eucharist becomes a venue for being united with the liberating Christ, and for fleshing what he stood for.  Christ lived and still lives in the people. The Eucharist must help open the eyes, the ears, the mouths, and consciousness of the people to their reality.  Also, it is a celebration that uses the native language, elements and resources of the people, thereby creating and strengthening community.

It was August 11, 2006, when I visited with my friends the community of the United Church of Christ in the Philippines in Victoria, Mindoro Oriental, to help in the preparations for the marriage ceremony of our couple comrades and to celebrate with them. We helped them preparing the physical arrangement of the church sanctuary and the ordo of matrimony. I was task to conceptualize a creative movement or cultural presentation. The concept was about love and relationship, and how it works for the benefit of our service and mission. The ceremony for my assessment became a liberating event for the community. Some said it was something unique and new for them. It broke the traditional ordo that is commonly use by our churches. It was simple yet meaningful, because it was grounded in their real-life situation. You can feel in the community the happiness and hope for the newly-weds.  The wedding entourage’s attire was simple and not costly but meaningful and liberating.

The liturgy of the people need not be costly; it can be simple but grounded in the feelings and emotions of the people. The liturgy we used in that wedding ceremony was prepared and planned rooted in the emotion and feeling of our two comrades, taking into consideration also the community where they belonged.  It is not the pastors themselves who makes or creates the liturgy, even for weddings.  The liturgy must be necessarily based on the people’s reality.  It must be the product of the minds of the people, and not by the pastors alone. The liturgy should cater to the communal feeling and emotions of the people on a particular occasion. It must become an avenue to express their wholeness and perspectives of relationship amidst the struggle for life. Liturgy is the expression of the theology of the people. The work of the people, liturgy is an exegesis of realities, an exegesis of opportunity for the people to overcome the oppressive system in their midst. Doing liturgy or creating liturgy is going into the people, because our text is the people, a living text of the realities of life. Creating liturgy is entering behind the text, behind the structural and institutional definition of the people’s life.

Understanding the Actions in the Eucharist
TAKING THE BREAD AND CUP is the first four actions of the Holy Eucharist, based on the actions of Jesus during their meeting at the Upper Room with his disciples. As the Gospels say, Jesus took some Bread and after the supper took the CUP. This is what we do during our Eucharistic celebration in remembrance of what he did, and just as the disciples experienced on the way to Emmaus (Luke 24:30). THE GREAT THANKSGIVING is the next act in the celebration of the Eucharist. After having taken the bread and wine, Jesus gave thanks over (blessed) the bread and cup. Then the second part of the liturgy begins with what we also call the Eucharistic Prayer. The prayer begins with the invitation to give thanks to God:

The Lord be with you.
And also with you.
Lift up your hearts. The pastor my lift hands and keep them raised.
We lift them up to the Lord.
Let us give thanks to the Lord our God.
It is rights to give our thanks and praise.

This is the introductory dialogue between the celebrant (ordained) and the people, and after this the pastor gives thanks appropriate to the occasion, remembering God’s acts of salvation. The invitation to give thanks to God, is an invitation of recognizing the liberating works of God in the past, at present, and in the future. God liberated God’s people so many times, and guided them in all circumstances. God opted to liberate God’s people, and this liberation was a political liberation.  During their journey out of Egypt, God accompanied them and protected them from any attack from the Egyptian forces that pursued them. God provided them food for the sustenance of their long march of liberation (Exodus 16:13-14). As they journeyed through the desert, their relationship with God developed all the more.  Their march saw the creation of their covenant with God as a community of faith.  They journeyed together with God towards socio-political liberation.
It is right, and a good and joyful thing,
always and everywhere to give thanks to you.
Father Almighty, creator of heaven and earth.
You formed us in your image
and breathed into us the breath of life.
When we turned away, and our love failed,
your love remained steadfast.
You delivered us from captivity,
made covenant to be our sovereign God,
and spoke to us through your prophets.

This part of the GREAT THANKSGIVING is what we also call The Preface. It is addressed to God and recalls what God has done in human history, in the history and struggles for the liberation of the people. Part of it is the Sanctus, which is also the next part.
The pastor may lower hands.

Holy, holy, holy Lord, God of power and might. Heaven and earth are full of your glory. Hosanna in the highest. Blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord. Hosanna in the highest.

This is a song of acclamation, adoration, and thanksgiving addressed to God our Parent. The phrase:  “Blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord” in between the two “Hossanas” was used by the disciples to hail the entrance of Jesus in Jerusalem. This phrase according to Louis Bouyer, was taken from the 118th chapter of Psalms. We can also refer to Isaiah 6:3, “Holy, holy, holy!...” a phrase shouted by the disciples when Jesus entered Jerusalem.   For the Christians, this became the paramount Easter Psalm. But for the Jews it was first a Psalm of enthronement, glorifying the Messiah-King’s entry into the Temple, the entry of the Lord himself into his sanctuary.[1] The preface continues by narrating that God sent God’s Son to us to heal, lift us up, and pardon. Jesus preached the Kingdom of God, as an alternative community that offers ultimate liberation of the people. A Kingdom of God in which social classes are eliminated as what he stressed in Mark 10:24.  “It is much harder for a rich person to enter the Kingdom of God that for a camel to go through the eye of a needle.” In Luke 6:20 “Happy are you poor; the Kingdom of God is yours!....” and in verse 24, “But how terrible for you who are rich now; you have had your easy life!”  It is a kingdom of God which seeks to “tear down the rulers from their thrones and lift up the lowly, to fill the hungry with good things and send the rich off with nothing” (Luke 1:52-53).

Jesus preached the Kingdom of God as an alternative community that offers ultimate liberation of the people. A Kingdom of God in which social classes are eliminated as what he stressed in Mark 10:24.  “It is much harder for a rich person to enter the Kingdom of God that for a camel to go through the eye of a needle.” In Luke 6:20 “Happy are you poor; the Kingdom of God is yours!....” and in verse 24, “But how terrible for you who are rich now; you have had your easy life!” A kingdom of God which seeks to “tear down the rulers from their thrones and lift up the lowly, to fill the hungering with good things and send the rich of with nothing” (Luke 1:52-53). What Jesus proclaimed is a new state of society, a new structure where the power of the people is lived out in a spontaneous loving service rendered to one another.

Holy are you, and blessed is your Son Jesus Christ.
Your Spirit anointed him
to preach good news to the poor,
to proclaim release to the captives
and recovering of sight to the blind,
to set at liberty those who are oppressed,
and to announce that the time had come
when you would save your people.
He healed the sick, fed the hungry, and ate with sinners.
By the baptism of his suffering, death, and resurrection
you gave birth to your Church,
delivered us from slavery to sin and death,
and made with us a new covenant
by water and the Spirit.
When the Lord Jesus ascended,
he promised to be with us always,
in the power of your Word and Holy Spirit.

It continues to highlight the continuing work of God through Christ, who became the good gift to us that enlightens and empowers the people. This part of the Eucharistic prayer also echoes that the divine promise of God that will be completely fulfilled.  The Eucharistic prayer deals with the public proclamation of the deeds of God, the hymn of praise, making known and recalling the Eucharistic assembly attended by Jesus Christ. It is followed by the Epiclesis, a prayer.  The term comes from the Greek “epi” meaning “over”, and “kaleo” meaning “to call” or “invoke.”  This is a prayer calling the Holy Spirit to come upon the bread and the cup in order that they may become the body and blood of Christ, which will make his people a body of Christ redeemed and manifesting the redeeming works of Christ. The epiclesis does not ask for a change in the bread and wine into the body and blood of Christ—although this may be implied by the following invocation:[2]
The pastor may hold hands, palms down, over the bread and cup.

Pour our you Holy Spirit on us gathered here,
and on these gifts of bread and wine.
Make them be for us the body and the blood of Christ,
that we may be for the world the body of Christ,
redeemed by his blood.

The pastor may raise hand.

By your Spirit make us one with Christ,
one with each other,
and one in ministry to all the world,
until Christ comes in final victory
and we feast at his heavenly banquet.

Through you Son Jesus Christ,
with the Holy Spirit in your holy Church,
and all honor and glory is yours, almighty Father,
now and for ever.

Amen.

Saying or singing “Amen” in the liturgy means we adhere to all that just been proclaimed. We manifest our affirmation and agreement with what has been done and narrated to us. We put ourselves into an agreement to all the things which the Eucharist does. “Amen” is the key word of our participation and continuation of the Lord’s mission and ministry. The recitation of “Amen” by all signifies the people’s affirmation and commitment to the mission and ministry of the Christian movement. After the Epiclesis is the Narration of the Institution, where the celebrants (pastors) pronounce the words of Christ used at the Last Supper. The words of institution is an integral part of the entire salvation story (1st Corinthians 11:23).

The pastor may hold hands, palms down, over the bread, or touch the bread, of lift the bread.

On the night in which he gave himself up for us,
he took bread, gave thanks to you, broke the bread,
gave it to his disciples, and said:
“Take, eat; this is my body which is given for you.
Do this in remembrance of me.”

The pastor may hold hands, palms down, over the cup, or touch the cup, of lift the cup.

When the supper was over, he took the cup,
gave thanks to you, gave it to his disciples, and said:
“Drink from this, all of you;
this is my blood of the new covenant,
poured out for you and for many
for the forgiveness of sins.
Do this, as often as you drink it,
in remembrance of me.”

Immediately after the narration of institution comes the so-called anamnesis, which means “remembrance”. William Willimon adapted the idea of Gregory Dix who “suggested that this should be translated, not as something remembered from the past, but as a “re-presentation” or “re-calling” of some past event, making it present.”[3]  According to William H. Willimon, to “remember does not mean mere historical recollection. It more nearly means to wake up, to open your eyes, to call to mind, to renew or re-awaken. Remember who you are.”[4] Remembering who we are today, in worship life and in our Eucharistic celebrations is to remember the experiences of the people to who we owe our origin of worship. The people of Palestine in the Greco-Roman period, their worship life, their faith, the tears and joys they experienced, their ups and downs, their socio-economic and political life, and their revolutionary movement. It is not merely historical reflection but also gives attention to our current situation.

The pastor may raise hand.

And so, in remembrance of these your mighty acts in Jesus Christ, we offer ourselves in praise and thanksgiving as a holy and living sacrifice, in union with Christ’s offering for us, as we proclaim the mystery of faith.

Christ has died; Christ is risen; Christ will come again.

The mystery of faith is referred to the mystery of Christ himself which is summarized into three events: his death, his resurrection, and his return at the end of time. This mystery of faith refers to our acclamation to Christ which indicates the necessary aspect of the Eucharist. This signifies the eschatological dimension of the Eucharist, looking forward and makes us look forward to the time that the Lord comes.

THE LORD’S PRAYER is a form and action that bridges the first pair of actions (TAKING THE BREAD AND CUP, and THE GREAT THANKSGIVING) and the second pair of actions (BREAKING THE BREAD, and GIVING THE BREAD AND CUP). It is a verbal entrance into communion with God that is holy beyond words. The people are called to a prayer with this invitation:

The pastor’s hand may be extended in open invitation.
And now, with the confidence of children of God, let us pray:
The pastor may raise hand.
Our Father in heaven,
hallowed be your name,
your kingdom come,
your will be done,
on earth as in heaven.
Give us today our daily bread.
Forgives us our sins
as we forgive those who sin against us.
Save us from the time of trial,
And deliver us from evil.
For the kingdom, the power, and the glory are yours
Now and forever. Amen.

Jesus is a man of prayer, every time, in every place, before and after he does something, he prays. Jesus prayed alone and with others, and the “Our Father” is a prayer that involved others. It is very clear that Jesus prayed not to “his Father” but to “Our Father” which is inclusive and universal. It implies a fundamental rejection of all forms of human discrimination and we are all under the parenthood of God. The “Our Father” that Jesus says is an expression of giving importance to our relationship to Him and to His people. The statement “Hollowed be your name” is a prayer that God’s holiness be manifest through us. His manifestation to the one praying is expressed in undertaking liberating acts against all forms of oppression.  The petition, “Your kingdom come, your will be done on earth as in heaven” is not simply related to the realization of the values of the Kingdom of God among people. But it refers specifically to the acceptance of God’s values by us, in our hearts and in our communities.  It is a radical invitation for a radical transformation and to an action for humanity. “Your kingdom come” is a prayer for the realization of an alternative society where exploitation of one person of another has no place. 

In this prayer, Jesus teach us to pray for our basic and fundamental needs and rights, “Give us today our daily bread”. “Give us” is a prayer that implies the concern for others. It is a resistance to situations of massive or spontaneous death due to hunger and malnutrition because they do not have food to eat. Jesus also taught us to forgive others. It is a revolutionary forgiveness that has something to do with the liberation of both oppressor and the oppressed in a transformed relationship. This is the essence of the Lord’s prayer, “Forgives us our sins as we forgive those who sin against us.” Our commitment for social justice must be nurtured by a profound love and compassion for others. “Save us from the time of trial, And deliver us from evil” is a petition to be delivered from personal and collective evil, selfishness within us and among us, opportunism and careerism. The Lord’s Prayer is a synthesis of the political program of Jesus giving the priority to the urgent needs of the people. 

The BREAKING OF THE BREAD is the third of the four actions of the Holy Eucharist. In the road to Emmaus, the disciples recognized Jesus not because of the food they ate but because of the breaking of it. The bread symbolizes life and that life is manifest in the people and lives with the people. The bread at the Lord’s Table is connected with the person and ministry of Jesus. The breaking of bread (fractio panis) symbolizes the life and purpose of Jesus Christ being shared and extended to his disciples, and to the people.  But this is not simply signifying sharing, but also an act telling his purpose and cause of existence. The bread was himself, and in breaking the bread Jesus was breaking himself. God through Jesus Christ had entered bodily into human brokenness to open up a space and time for the people to be reconciled with God and with one another.

The pastor, still standing behind the Lord’s table facing the people, breaks the bread in silence, or while saying:

Because there us one loaf,
we, who are many, are one body, for we all partake of the one loaf.
The bread which we break is a sharing in the body of Christ.

The pastor lifts the cup in silence, or while saying:

The cup over which we give thanks is a sharing in the blood of Christ.

Jesus, in his meal with the disciples, spoke of the wine as his blood—the blood of the new covenant (Jeremiah 31:31-34) between God and the people. He also spoke of the wine as a sign of the heavenly banquet that he will celebrate with the church in the future (1 Corinthians 11:23-26). Wine is a powerful symbol of the unity of the body of Christ gathered at the Lord’s Table. The juice of the red grape in a common cup represents the church’s covenant with Christ’s, established through his atoning death (Hebrews 9:15-28; 13:20-21). The cup and to drink from it is an expression of our willingness to take part in his passion and mission. As we raise the cup, we propose a toast of commitment.

GIVING THE BREAD AND CUP is the fourth and last action of the Holy Eucharist. This action commemorates and makes present the central event of our faith: the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus, his life and ministries that inaugurates the alternative kingdom of God, and the giving of his life to others. The sharing of bread and cup equally is an act of protest against their current situation imposed by the authorities. There was no equal distribution then of resources.  There was economic and political opportunism, a repressive system where a lot of people starved to death due to the unequal treatment and distribution of wealth.  The bread and the cup, the sharing of it projects that our aspirations to have a community that allows us to enjoy peace and justice is possible. The sharing is an open invitation, and any or all of the people may receive them while standing, kneeling, or seated. It is our custom to serve each person individually, while exchanging these or other words:

The bread and wine are given to the people, with these or other words being exchange:

The Body of Christ, is given for you. Amen.
The Blood of Christ, is given for you. Amen.

After all have received, the final prayer will be uttered by the celebrant (pastor). This prayer recalls all the blessings we have received by means of our communion with the bread and cup. And asking that this sharing will progress and live out into the world to bear and produce fruits. This is a final word of commitment that we want to keep in our head and mind in doing our responsibilities again in our every day life and journey. 

The congregation may sing hymns while the bread and cup are given. While all have received, the Lord’s table is pun in order. The following prayer is then offered by the pastor or by all:

Eternal God, we give you thanks for this holy mystery
in which you have given yourself to us.
Grant that we may go into the world
in the strength of you Spirit,
to give ourselves for others,
in the name of Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.

The consecrated elements are consumed in the context of the gathered community, and it may be extended to those unable to attend because of age, illness, or similar conditions. The United Methodist community has been recovering the fullness of Word and Table as the pattern for weekly worship on the Lord’s Day. We encourage to advocate the general orders of Sunday Worship in The United Methodist Hymnal and The United Methodist Book of Worship. The United Methodist Church is encouraged to continue participating in Eucharistic celebrations in ecumenical settings, with due respect and openness to learning. The United Methodist Church affirms its ecumenical commitment in its Constitution that, “as part of the church universal, The United Methodist Church believes that the Lord of the Church is calling Christians everywhere to strive toward unity; and therefore it will seek, and work for, unity at all levels of church life.”[5] We have been expressing our commitment to promote ecumenical sharing by entering into agreements that enhance the unity of the church, participating in the development of the Baptism, Eucharist, and Ministry through the Word Council of Churches that affirms the significance of the sacrament in the Christian communities. ####

References:
1.        Baker, Frank. METHODISM AND LOVE-FEAST. London: The Epworth Press, 1957.
2.        Balasuriya, Tissa. OMI. THE EUCHARIST AND HUMAN LIBERATION. New York: Orbis Books, 1979.
3.        Bedell, Kenneth B. Worship in the Methodist Tradition. USA: Discipleship Resources Tidings, 1976.
4.        Best, Thomas F. and Heller Dagmar (eds.). EUCHARISTIC WORSHIP IN
5.        ECUMENICAL CONTEXT: The Lima Liturgy – and Beyond. Switzerland: WCC Publications, 1998.
6.        __________________________________. Se We Believe, So We Pray: Towards Koinonia in Worship. Switzerland: WCC Publications, 1995.
7.        Cameron, Richard M. METHODISM AND SOCIETY IN HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE. Vol. 1. USA: Abingdon Press, 1961.
8.        Crossan, John Dominic. Jesus: A Revolutionary Biography. USA: Harper Collins Publishers, Inc., 1994.
9.        Deats, Richard L. NATIONALISM AND CHRISTIANITY IN THE PHILIPPINES. Dallas: Southern Methodist University Press, 1967.
10.     Elwood, Douglas J. and Magdamo, Patricia L. CHRIST IN THE PHILLIPINE CONTEXT. Quezon City: New Day Publishers, 1971.
11.     Garneau, Jean-Yves. DISCOVERING THE EUCHARIST: According to a Ritual Approach. Philippines: St. Paul, 1990.
12.     Glatzer, Nahum N. (ed.). THE PASSOVER HAGGADAH. New York: Schocken Books, 1979.
13.     Hann, Ferdinand. The Worship of the Early Church. USA: Fortress Press, 1973.
14.     Heitzenrater, Richard P. WESLEYAN and the People Called Methodist. USA: Abingdon Press, 1995.
15.     Hellwig, Monika K. THE EUCHARIST & THE HUNGER OF THE WORLD. Makati City: St. Pauls Philippines, 2003.
16.     Hickman, Hoyt L. Worshipping With United Methodist: A Guide for Pastors and Church Leaders. Nashville: Abingdon Press, 1996.
17.     Hurtado, Larry H. At the ORIGINS of CHRISTIAN WORSHIP: The Context and Character of Earliest Christian Devotion. USA: William B. Eerdmans Publishing Company, 1999.
18.     Khoo, Lorna Lock-Nah. Wesleyan Eucharistic Spirituality: Its Nature, Sources and Future. Australia: Australian Theological Forum Press, 2005.
19.     Kodell, Jerome. OSB. The Eucharist in the New Testament.  Manila: St. Pauls Philippines, 1995.
20.     Langford, Thomas Anderson III (Gen. Ed.). THE UNITED METHODIST BOOK OF WORSHIP. USA: The United Methodist Publishing House, 2002.
21.     Marquardt, Manfred. John Wesley’s Social Ethics: Praxis and Principles. USA: Abingdon Press, 1992.
22.     Martin, Ralph P. WORSHIP IN THE EARLY CHURCH. Grand Rapids: William B. Eerdmans Publishing Company, 2000.
23.     Maxwell, William D. An Outline of CHRISTIAN WORSHIP: Its Developments and Forms. Great Britain: Oxford University Press, 1960.
24.     Nolan, Albert. Jesus Before Christianity. Quezon City: Claretian Publications, 1985.
25.     Pazmiño, Robert W. Foundational Issues in Christian Education: An Introduction in Evangelical Perspective. USA: Baker Books, 2003.
26.     Rieger, Joerg. and Vincent, John J. METHODIST AND RADICAL: Rejuvenating a Tradition. USA: Kingswood Books, Abingdon Press, 2003.
27.     Tejon, Guillermo. OP. The MASS We Celebrate. Pasay City: Paulines Publishing House, 1997.
28.     Vaño, Manolo O. Discovering the Original Jesus: A Biography of a Revolutionary Genius as He was Actively Known to His Contemporaries. Quezon City: New Day Publisher, 1998.
29.     Voigt, Edwin E. METHODIST WORSHIP IN THE UNIVERSAL CHURCH. USA: Graded Press, 1965.
30.     Weber, Theodore R. POLITICS IN THE ORDER OF SALVATION: Transforming Wesleyan Political Ethics. USA: Abingdon Press, 2001.
31.     White, James F. INTRODUCTION TO CHRISTIAN WORSHIP. USA: Abingdon Press, 1980.
32.     Willimon, William H. SUNDAY DINNER: The Lord’s Supper and the Christian Life. USA: The Upper Room, 1981.
33.     _________________. Word, Water, Wine and Bread: How Worship Has Changed over the Years. USA: Judson Press, 1980.
34.     Willimon, William H. and Wilson, Robert L. “Preaching and Worship in the Small Church” in Creative Leadership Series. Ed. By Lyle E. Schaller. USA: Abingdon Press, 1980.
35.     THE UNITED METHODIST HYMNAL. USA: The United Methodist Publishing House, 2005.
36.     THE UNITED METHODIST BOOK OF WORSHIP. USA: The United Methodist Publishing House, 2002.
37.     THE UNITED METHODIST BOOK OF DISCIPLINE. USA: The United Methodist Publishing House, 2000.
38.     Anno, Ferdinand C. “Doing Worship in the Context of a People’s Struggle for Life” in The Union Seminary Bulletin. Yr. 1. Vol. 1, November 2002.
39.     _______________. “The Subversive Pilgrim and the Liturgical Rhetoric of Struggle” in ANUMANG HIRAP, KUNG HINDI MASIKIP AY MALUWANG: Iba’t-Ibang Anyo ng Teolohiyang Pumipiglas. Published by the Union Theological Seminary, 2006.
40.     Larranga, Jose Miguel, SSS. “The Eucharist in the Theology of Liberation” in The Emmanuel. Philippine Edition, 2001.
41.     This Holy Mystery: A United Methodist Understanding of Holy Communion. USA: General Board of Discipleship of the United Methodist Church, 2004.



[1] Louis Bouyer, EUCHARIST: Theology and Spirituality of the Eucharistic Prayer, (USA: University of Notre Dame Press, 1968), p.231.
[2] William H. Willimon, WORD, Water, Wine and Bread…, p. 38.

[3] Ibid, p. 37.
[4] William H. Willimon, Sunday Dinner: The Lord’s Supper and the Christian Life, p.21.
[5] UMC Book of Discipline, par. 5.